Good morning, Penny, and all my gardening friends:) Penny, this is the first time I ever made this recipe for red cabbage, which I obtained from Epicurious.com, by way of House and Garden, February 1964. I modified it as I went along, and you may you, if you so desire. Here it is: 1 medium red cabbabe, (about 3 lbs.) 3 Tablespoons of butter 1 tablespoon sugar, or more, according to taste 1/2 cup vinegar (I used more than 1/2 cup) Salt (I used 2 teaspoons over the entire cooking time, started out with 1) Pepper to taste (I was generous towards the end, correcting seasoning) 2 medium tart apples ( I used Granny Smiths) 1/2 cup red currant jelly (a wonderful addition!) [a generous Tablespoon of caraway seeds; my addition] Remove and discard tough outer leaves from cabbage. Shred cabbage very finely (I used my 2 mm disk in the Cuisinart). I heavy [notstick]skillet, melt butter. Add sugar, but do not brown. Add cabbage and cook 3 minutes, stirring constantly. Add vinegar, water [I added 1/4 cup], salt and peppre to taste. Simmer covrered for 2-3 hours [mine was done in about 1 1/2 hours], or until cabbage was very tender. Stir occasionally, and if necessary, add a little hot water to prevent scorching. When cabbage is almost tender, add apples [cored and cut up into little pieces], if desired, and red currant jelly [and caraway seeds]. Cabbage should be quite sweet-sour. If necessary, add more sugar or vinegar, a little at t time. Simmer covrered for 30 minutes or longer, stirring occasionally. Serve with roast duck or goose. This is best made a day ahead of time [I made mine Sunday morning], and reheated slowly. Enjoy! Ron