Rock phosphate is so insoluble in alkaline soils that it is of little or no value as a source of plant available phosphorus. I was assuming rock dust to be a powder form of rock phosphate (not certain if that is so) and it would also be insoluble. It is probably great for acid soils. There was a thread on this topic 2-3 years ago on the U of A arid_gardener listserv. The final word is from the U of A soils department archived at http://ag.arizona.edu/hypermail/arid_gardener/0411.html. As you suggest, mineral depletion is not a normally problem in our desert soil with the possible exception of iron and zinc (required by citrus) which are deficient in some areas. -Olin -----Original Message----- From: Thomas Giannou <thomas@tandjenterprises.com> Subject: Re: [tomato] blights >... why would rock dust be inappropriate to desert soils? ... Perhaps in your soils mineral >depletion by plants may not be a problem? .../