Hi Matt, I don't think you did bad about watering the potatos. As long as the plants don't look wilty you weren't under watering them. One of the major problems with potatos is rot. The wetter the more likely they are to rot. When I plant I till the soil until it is nice and loose, then pull it together in a wide row, at least 24 inches across. I dig a trench in the center of the row about 6 inches deep. I add fertilizer to this trench and cover with about 3 inches of soil. Then I plant my potatos and cover them with the last 3 inches of soil. The easiest way for me to get the 3" to cover the fertilizer and the 3" to cover the potatos is by covering the fertilizer with the soil on one side of the trench and coming back to cover the potatos with the soil on the other side of the trench. When I use a hoe to open the trench it throws soil to both sides of the trench. When the potatos plants are about 6" tall I start pulling dirt up around the stem to the bottom of the leaves. I keep "dirting" them as they grow taller. The potato plant makes all of its potatos from the top of the seed piece to the surface. The higher the soil is on the plant the more room it has to make potatos. I think that you might be a little late for fall potatos. There is only about 6 weeks left before you could expect a frost. You would make some potatos but they would just about all be small. I have known people who have planted potatos for the first time use potatos from the produce section at the store. These potatos almost always fail to make a crop because they are treated so they won't sprout before they can be used. When you cut your seed pieces one or two eyes are fine. The important part is that they are on a chunk of potato about 1" square or nearly so. Bigger is ok. Until the potato starts to sprout and make its own roots this piece has to supply the sprout with food. These cut pieces must be treated with something to keep them from getting diseased or from shriveling. The books suggest sulfur among other things. I use wood ashes like my grandfather and my dad did. It works like a champ and is cheaper than the other stuff. Put the wood ashes in a bag add a couple hands full of pieces and shake. I do this the day before I plant them. I put the treated pieces on cardboard or brown paper with a little space between them so they will air dry. I have read a book called Square Foot Gardening. It seems like an interesting concept but since I have enough room and experience in the traditional row gardening I stick to that. If it ain't broke don't fix it. My neighbor is an advocate of another type gardening called "flat gardening". Instead of rows he just plants on flat ground and spaces the plants 18 to 24 inches apart left to right. The plants are in "rows" but not hilled up if you know what I mean. His yields on the same type soil are about 25% of mine. His potatos and other vegetables are way smaller than mine. My largest red potatos were the size of soft balls. His were about the size of tennis balls. He also has a lot of losses from root rot. By using the traditional hilled up rows air and water pass through the sides of the rows. It also keeps the soil from compacting to the point that the roots can't get oxygen.My sandy loam will crust from time to time. I take a garden rake and drag the rake so that it just breaks the surface on the side of the rows so that air and water can pass through. My county extension agent says that the veggie garden needs the equivalent of 1" of rain per week. The only way I know how to do that is use a sprinkler and a rain gauge that comes with some of them. After the plants have leaves on them most city or treated water will burn the leaves and wet leaves are more susceptible to fungus and mildew. Most of my watering is row irrigation. I make soil dams every 4-6 ft and let the water trickle down the row. It fills up between dams and then will break the dam and go to the next one. This allows water to soak in and be pulled up the sides of the row by osmosis. I do this about every three days. It might supply the minimum but it won't over water which is bad if not worse than just meeting the minimum. Whew!! I hope I haven't bored you to death. I can just rave on about gardening. I love it and try to share what I have learned. I do have a tendency to go on and on. If I can help you in any way just ask. I'll try and probably fail to be less long winded. Allen Bastrop Co.,Tx