Re: [tomato] Tomato Digest V1 #149
Thomas J. Keehn (Tomato@GlobalGarden.com)
Mon, 01 Mar 1999 19:31:23 -0800
please discontinue sending me your newsletter, i am no longer interested in
receiving it. THank you. At 03:22 AM 2/19/99 -0800, you wrote:
>Tomato Digest Friday, February 19 1999 Volume 01 : Number 149
>
>
>
>In this issue:
>
> Re: [tomato] Plant in the same spot or not?
> Re: [tomato] Plant in the same spot or not?
> RE: [tomato] What to Grow in NY
>
>See the end of the digest for information on subscribing to the tomato
>or tomato-digest mailing lists and on how to retrieve back issues.
>
>----------------------------------------------------------------------
>
>Date: Thu, 18 Feb 1999 07:32:33 -0700
>From: margaret lauterbach <mlaute@micron.net>
>Subject: Re: [tomato] Plant in the same spot or not?
>
>At 11:27 PM 2/17/99 EST, you wrote:
>>I just joined this list last week. I'd like your opinion(s) before planting
>>time gets here. Do you rotate the location where you plant tomatoes from
one
>>year to the next?
>>
>>I've been growing tomatoes for about 10 years. I have always heard that I
>>should rotate where the tomatoes are grown each year to help prevent soil
>>borne diseases. Last year, on a different maillist, many people said that
>>rotating tomatoes isn't necessary. If I remember correctly, two of their
>>reasons were 1) healthy plants could handle typical soil borne diseases
>>fairly well, and 2) soil high in organic material would supress those
>>diseases.
>>
>>Last year (for the first time), I planted my tomatoes in the same spot as
the
>>previous year's tomatoes. I didn't have any major problems, nor did I
have a
>>great year. I'm debating whether to continue rotating or not.
>>
>>Thanks for your opinions
>>Tom
>>
>I've been told by our Extension agent that she saw research that reported
>tomatoes prepare the ground for more tomatoes. She can't recall the
>source. I've grown tomatoes in the same patch since 1972 except for one
>year when I planted them elsewhere. That year I lost 50% of my plants to
>disease. I decided not to rotate tomatoes any more, especially since I had
>had no disease problems in the original patch. The weather in most of the
>country last year was not very conducive to growing tomatoes. Best,
>Margaret
>
>------------------------------
>
>Date: Thu, 18 Feb 1999 08:39:31 -0800 (PST)
>From: ryarnell@orednet.org (Richard Yarnell)
>Subject: Re: [tomato] Plant in the same spot or not?
>
>Here is a decidedly unscientific response:
>
>We leased some land in Southern Cal to a family which first raised
>strawberries and then tomatoes on it. Subsequently, we planted Avocados
>on the same land. We traced the problems which ultimately led to taking
>that parcel out of the Avocado orchard to the tomatoes.
>
>If memory serves, and it must go back to the 50's, we concluded that,
>unless you rotate crops in the same family (eg. potatoes) on less than a 3
>or four year schedule, or if you are working in marginal soil, the
>problems will not be severe. However, if you have blight or any number of
>other persistent diseases, even heavy composting will not cure the problem.
>If you have the room, establish a rotation and stick to it. With the
>spread of late blight, I think it's doubly important to keep the reservoir
>of infectious diseases at a minimum.
>
>On a related topic, we suggest that you not compost potatoes, potato
>plants, tomatoes or other related plants even if you use a rapid compost
>regimen. On a small scale, there are always margins of a composting mass
>which don't reach or hold "high" temperatures long enough.
>
>RY
>
>>At 11:27 PM 2/17/99 EST, you wrote:
>
>>>Do you rotate the location where you plant tomatoes from one
>>>year to the next?
>
>>>I've been growing tomatoes for about 10 years. I have always heard that I
>>>should rotate where the tomatoes are grown each year to help prevent soil
>>>borne diseases. Last year, on a different maillist, many people said that
>>>rotating tomatoes isn't necessary. If I remember correctly, two of their
>>>reasons were 1) healthy plants could handle typical soil borne diseases
>>>fairly well, and 2) soil high in organic material would supress those
>>>diseases.
>
>- ---------------
>Richard Yarnell, SHAMBLES WORKSHOPS | No gimmick we try, no "scientific"
>Beavercreek, OR. Makers of fine | fix we attempt, will save our planet
>Wooden Canoes, The Stack(R) urban | until we reduce the population. Let's
>composter, fly tying benches | leave our kids a decent place to live.
>
>- --
>
>
>------------------------------
>
>Date: Thu, 18 Feb 1999 16:29:59 -0500
>From: "Byron.Bromley" <Byron.Bromley@gsd-co.com>
>Subject: RE: [tomato] What to Grow in NY
>
>I live in Sourthern NH about 200 mi east of you.
>I select a 90 day to maturity variety, I start about 12 weeks early
>so I have a 12 to 16 in plant in a 4x6in pot (Mostly newspaper)
>to reduce root trauma at transplanting.
>
>You live in Zone 4 Last typical frost May 20th and first
>normal ?? is Sept 10. Normal plant out is Memorial Day
>And start thinking about frost covers on Labor Day
>
>For paste tomatoes try the Amish Paste, lot more flavor
>and larger. Needs staking for 6ft plant, and a lot of sucker
>growth
>
>Byron
>
>------------------------------
>
>End of Tomato Digest V1 #149
>****************************
>
>To subscribe to tomato-digest, send the command:
>
> subscribe
>
>in the body of a message to "tomato-digest-request@GlobalGarden.com".
>
>A non-digest (direct mail) version of this list is also available; to
>subscribe to that instead, replace all instances of "tomato-digest"
>in the commands above with "tomato".
>
>Back issues are available for anonymous FTP from ftp.globalgarden.com, in
>pub/tomato/digest/vNN.nMMM (where "NN" is the volume number, and "MMM"
>is the issue number).
>